The Promise Vs. the Payout

We all experience it – something comes to mind that we want to do or eat and it becomes hard to put it off.  We become almost consumed by it. Sometimes we have already done it before it seems we even thought about it.  This is especially problematic, however, when we know the thing we want isn’t helpful for us: anger outbursts, compulsive eating, pornography, shopping, doom scrolling, etc.  While the process I will share here is not likely sufficient by itself to help you change, it can go a long way to decrease the compulsion.  

When ideas come to us, they also come with emotions and images of how good it will feel to do the thing.  This is what I refer to as “the promise”. “The promise” is your expectations for how good it will feel to do the thing you want.  For example, if there is a little sweat or treat on the counter (or in the snack room at work), when you see it or think of it, you start to imagine how good it would feel to eat it.  You likely even start to salivate.  This promise of expectations can be pretty strong and overwhelming, compelling you to do the desired thing.   Another example: someone is rude to you and you think how redeeming it would feel to say that witty put-down that just came to mind.  Or, you are feeling overwhelmed by difficulty and the idea of numbing out through doom scrolling or pornography sounds/feels really compelling. You may often find yourself engaging in the behavior before you even realized you were considering it – it just happens. But in reality, the expectations of “the promise” compelled you to action, before you were even consciously aware you were experiencing it. 

What are the behaviors in your life that come with a strong compulsion, or a strong promise of how good they will feel?  Take a moment to think of a few. Try to bring up this feeling of “the promise” that each of them offers.  In your mind, when you consider them, they seem just right and perfect for what you need at that moment and thus they are difficult to resist.  That feeling is “the promise” of the behavior, or the promised payoff or feelings that supposedly come with it.  

Next, I want you to try to pay attention to the actual payout – how it really feels to do the thing. Try to reflect on how it usually feels just after you have indulged.  How do you feel after doom scrolling for 30 minutes?  How does it feel just after you eat the treat?  How do you feel after putting another person down?  This is what I refer to as “the payout” – how it actually feels after doing the behavior.  Maybe you have noticed this, but perhaps you stay so stuck in “the promise” that you notice less the actual payout.  This is how we often get stuck in behavior loops that don’t really work for us.  

“The Promise” of how good you will feel is often inconsistent with the actual “Payout.”  Some things over-promise, and others underpromise.  Starting to notice this more helps you make better choices.

I lived for a few years in the South American country of Colombia.  The treats they had there were different from what I was used to, and for me, rarely paid out the way I hoped.  During this time, it became easier for me to resist treats, because I realized they just didn’t pay off how I hoped.  At the same time, other items, like fresh baked bread, did seem to pay off and I wanted more of it.  These experiences set me on a path to paying more attention to whether things pay off the way I hope.  Some things do and some don’t.

Now, my guess is that at this point, you are mentally trying to tell me that the things you do indulge in really pay off.  That special chocolate candy, or some other great reward.  I don’t mean to suggest most things don’t pay off.  In fact, some do.  Other things, like helping others, doing difficult work, and learning something new seem to pay out in much better ways than they promise.  Who wants to go work really hard at something right now?  The promise isn’t very good.  But hopefully you have had a few experiences where you notice that hard work, or helping someone else, or sacrificing yourself for another can have a pretty great payout.  

If the things you are doing really pay off, then you probably want to keep doing them.  However, my experience and that of my clients is that we keep doing things that don’t really pay off.  Could that be true for you as well?  Do you keep doing them because of “the promise”?  If so, this may be helpful.  The next time you feel tempted toward something, just try to hold that for a while and pay attention to what the promise feels like.  What does it make you believe will be so good about it?  Maybe even take down some notes if you can, but at least take a moment to be present with the promised payout and notice what you think it will give you.  Then, engage in the behavior.  After you have done so, again pay attention and be present to notice how you actually feel?  Do you feel as good and as satisfied as you expected?  Pay attention to all your feelings, as some are likely conflicting.  Notice them all!  If you are truly satisfied as you expected, this behavior is probably worth continuing.  If not, one way to decrease your turning to it is to more fully notice each time that it does not actually pay off.  Don’t get distracted by shame and completely miss paying attention to this payout.  That is a common mistake people make that keeps them in the negative loop.  Let yourself really experience the payout, without beating yourself up at the same time.

When you repeatedly recognize that a behavior doesn’t pay off as well as you thought, your impulse to engage in it will decrease.  For small things, this may be sufficient.  For harder things, including addictions, you probably need more than this, but it will help some nonetheless.  At the same time, for behaviors that come with little promise, but a great payoff, or even behaviors that come with a great promise, and a great payoff, you will want to increase these.  LIfe has so many challenges, so please, make good use of the things that truly pay off!

Make a list for yourself now – what behaviors you would like to pay attention to and better notice differences that may exist between “the promise” and “the payout”?  You can’t do them all at once and it takes some patience and perseverance to truly notice and give proper attention.  For many, it will take a lot of work to not let shame distract you from noticing “the payout”.  Make your list, and commit to working your way through it.  Your future self will thank you!

I would love to hear your thoughts. What things are over promising and what things are under promising in your life?

View other Articles / Topics

Learn more about Scott

Scroll to Top